Spotlighted Cases Show Depth of Survivor Shaming.
An earth-shattering report published by the Associated Press on December 4, 2023, revealed, with the help of a young Idaho survivor’s cell phone recordings, how the Church uses a damage control playbook to keep its image clean. The AP acquired cell phone audio recorded by 38-year-old Chelsea Goodrich of Ketchum, Idaho, who alleges that her father, a popular Idaho dentist and Mormon bishop, sexually abused her for years.
The case is a reasonable template for hundreds of other Mormon Church child sex abuse cases, sometimes brought to light after many years.
“’The adversary I’m sure worked on me,” John Goodrich said, using a Church term for Satan. “And that’s when it was going through my mind when I climbed in bed with Chelsea and was really aroused … with the intent of spooning and snuggling you but I didn’t… It was fun as heck, but it was wrong.” Later when police were handcuffing him, he protested that he did nothing wrong and was not ashamed of anything.
Despite receiving $300,000 of hush money from Kirton McConkie (sweetened from $90,000), in exchange for a signed confidentiality agreement with her and her mother Lorraine, and the promise to destroy the tapes, Chelsea says she is speaking out now to protect other children.
John Goodrich was arrested and facing a long prison sentence, but the charges were dropped when the bishop who heard his confession was discouraged from testifying under threat of being sued for millions of dollars for bucking clergy-penitent privilege. This happened in a recent Arizona case, among others.8